im sure on this forum most will say bmw.lol i had the same thing end of last year and opted for the beemer for 3 reasons. 1, i think its a better all round road bike than the R1. 2, you get more for your money, more trick bits and 3, the R1's were about to be recalled to be stripped apart as there was a gearbox issue and i didnt want that on a bike so new. you need to ride both and see what you like. there both good bikes imo