Having now spent around 6 hours on the r I have a clear opinion on the bike.
Lets start with the blatantly obvious stuff. Loads of power, no fairing to speak of, upright wide bar position, chain drive, auto blipper and a rather enormous Akra end can. The looks are marmite, but I kinda like it. Get rid of the cat and the end can with an expensive full system, tail tidy, maybe lose the side fairings completely (they are just for show, might as well get proper naked), and there sits a 170ish bhp naked monster.
Handling?
I noticed the demo bike rear tyre was low on tread in the middle when I gave it a once over before setting off from the dealer. And it makes complete sense. This bike goes like a rocket, it is just brilliant at eating traffic. A row of vehicles up ahead doing around 50 can be dispatched in a few seconds, flick the bike out, squirt on the power, flick it back in, engine braking, job done. Twisty roads, great, humps, great, sweeping bends great, traffic great. Blipper superb, brakes excellent, acceleration mind blowing. This bike works so well if ridden like a ****, banging up and down the box, weaving in and out, diving about, which is, let's be honest, really good fun, if not upsetting to all other road users over the age of 60. Sorry, not. Nothing new here then, powerful naked BMW bike, job done.
Brilliant? except this bike really is completely naked bar a comedy screen in front of the clocks, so anything above legal limits and I start thinking I need some more gym time just to hang on to the bars.
And it gets a bit worse because of that. Having to hang on for dear life makes feel through the bars a bit of a guess. There is no finesse at speed, the front can't settle itself naturally because I'm gripping the bars hard to save claiming on my life insurance, I am constantly wrestling it to go where it needs to go, which it happily does, but if it did decide to let go I don't think I'd know about until I was face first into the tarmac. And that plays on my mind because with no fairings, this is the kind of exposure only Jordan's tits would be comfortable with.
And then we have the DDC. The r is, well, a 3 settings bike, rain, road, and dynamic. There is a dynamic + mode too but screw that, the manual talks about dynamic mode as a way to 'test your riding skills' which wasn't the reassuring phrase I would expect to see in a politically correct, sanitised manual from ze Germans but hey ho. I first set off in dynamic but soon found the suspension damping was so hard it was unbearable, and we are not talking bad roads. Flicked it to road mode and it got a whole lot better, but still bone jarring in places. This is not the plush ddc on the HP4 or the 3rd gen rr.
Having said all that I can't fault it as a stand alone proposition. It's not perfect but it's a very very good bike.
The problem isn't so much with the r itself, the problem is that the rr exists and I'd have one of those every time instead. The rr is better everywhere.