I spent a while in get geared yesterday looking at new gloves. My criteria is maximum protection with good feeling and movement.
it was obvious looking at the Knox gloves that the outside seam design was begging to be a weak point, but I guess Knox know their stuff, just doesn't seem right to me. The plastic back of hand design to stop overextension just did not work when I put them on. I've got plenty of Knox armour products and love their tech, but the gloves just don't do it for me.
although this thread is a Knox question I thought this may be useful: I was impressed by the alpine stars gp pro gloves (not normally an AS fan, too blingy and not convinced about quality control) and the Held Titans. Both offered armour / padding in the critical areas and were supple enough for track / sport riding. The alpine stars were more comfortable, but the Titans had that little bit more armour. It is clearly a case of you get what you pay for. Looking at all the gloves, as the price increased so did the level of protection offered. I'll buy the titans when the store gets the right colour size combination in for me.
i must say the get geared shop in Leeds is very good. The guy I spent ages with yesterday showed me his gp pro gloves he'd had a fast high side at Cadwell on recently, so we could see how the gloves had performed in an off (very well tbh). Top service.